PuppyBase

English Setter vs Scottish Terrier

Side-by-side comparison across all 14 AKC trait ratings, with a clear verdict on which breed fits which kind of household.

Perfect Puppy Quiz · 5 questions · 90 seconds

Not sure which breed fits your life?

Answer five questions about your home, your schedule, and your tolerance for shedding. We’ll match you to your top three breeds from over 200.

The bottom line

English Setter vs Scottish Terrier

You might be comparing an English Setter and a Scottish Terrier because both are classic, charismatic breeds with long histories and strong personalities but that’s where the similarity ends. Think of them as two very different kinds of companions who just happen to share a love for their people. The English Setter is the joyful, rangy athlete of the pair. Picture weekend hikes, games of fetch in a fenced yard, and a dog who melts into your family like he was born into it. He’s goofy and warm, great with kids, and thrives when there’s space to stretch his legs. But don’t be fooled by his mellow downtime. This dog needs regular grooming, daily movement, and mental puzzles to stay balanced. Skip the brushing and you’ll regret it. He’s not for someone who lives in a studio and works 60-hour weeks. The Scottish Terrier is the feisty, compact guardian with a beard and a mind of his own. He’s confident, bold, and will bark at the mailman just because he can. He fits perfectly in an apartment and doesn’t need acres to be happy. But he’s not as easygoing with kids or other pets. Training a Scottie takes patience and consistency. He’ll learn, but on his terms. Here’s the truth beyond the data: the Setter wants to join your life. The Scottie will let you join his. If you want a partner in adventure who adores your whole family, go for the Setter. If you want a loyal, opinionated little guy who’s all yours and only yours, the Scottie’s your match.

English Setter
Scottish Terrier
23–27 in
Height
9.5–10 in
45–80 lb
Weight
18–22 lb
12–12 yr
Lifespan
12–12 yr
$1.2–3.0k
Puppy price
$1.5–3.5k
#94
AKC popularity
#57

Trait-by-trait

Higher bar = more of that trait. Shedding, barking, drooling, grooming flipped for readability.
Affectionate w/ Family
Good with Young Children
Good with Other Dogs
Shedding Level
Coat Grooming
Drooling Level
Good with Strangers
Playfulness
Watchdog / Protective
Adaptability
Trainability
Energy Level
Barking Level
Mental Stimulation Needs
AffectionGood w/ KidsGood w/ DogsShedding LevelGroomingDrooling LevelGood w/ StrangersPlayfulnessProtectiveAdaptabilityTrainabilityEnergy LevelBarking LevelMental Stim.
English Setter Scottish Terrier
Overlay

Where they diverge

Good with Other Dogs
English Setter is better with other dogs (2-point difference)
English
Watchdog / Protective
Scottish Terrier is more protective (2-point difference)
Scottish
Good with Young Children
English Setter is better with kids (1-point difference)
English
Shedding Level
Scottish Terrier sheds less (1-point difference)
Scottish
Drooling Level
Scottish Terrier drools less (1-point difference)
Scottish
The verdict

Choose the English Setter if…

  • Active families
  • Hunters
  • Homes with a yard
  • You value good with other dogsEnglish Setter scores noticeably higher.

Choose the Scottish Terrier if…

  • Apartment living
  • Independent owners
  • Those wanting a distinctive, classic breed
  • You value watchdog / protectiveScottish Terrier scores higher here.
English Setter Owner’s Guide
Everything you need before bringing your English Setter home.
Breed variants, breeder red flags, and what to ask
First-week checklist and daily schedules by age
Training timeline from 8 weeks to adulthood
Health screenings, emergency card, and feeding portions
Grooming schedule, first-year costs, and what nobody tells you
Get Your Guide
Scottish Terrier Owner’s Guide
Everything you need before bringing your Scottish Terrier home.
Breed variants, breeder red flags, and what to ask
First-week checklist and daily schedules by age
Training timeline from 8 weeks to adulthood
Health screenings, emergency card, and feeding portions
Grooming schedule, first-year costs, and what nobody tells you
Get Your Guide

Other comparisons people run