American Water Spaniel vs Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever

People compare the American Water Spaniel and the Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever because they’re both mid-sized, water-loving sporting dogs with tight curls and a hunting past. But that’s where the similarities taper off. If you're torn between them, what you're really choosing is style of energy, not just size or looks. The American Water Spaniel is the quieter, more contained package. At 25. 45 pounds and with moderate energy, it’s happy with a solid daily hike and some time in the water. It’s trainable and loyal, but doesn’t demand constant engagement. It’s the dog you can take duck hunting one weekend and then settle into a quiet cabin the next. But don’t be fooled by its calm demeanor. it’s not a couch potato. It needs purpose, and if you don’t provide it, it’ll find its own, like dismantling your shoe collection. The Toller? The Toller is a lightning bolt in dog form. Bred to dance along shorelines, luring ducks within range by playing, it’s got a manic joy that never fully turns off. That 5/5 energy means you’ll need to be active. really active. Agility, flyball, long swims, daily off-leash runs. It’s more kid-friendly, more affectionate, and far more adaptable to different homes. just as long as those homes move at its pace. Here’s the real talk: the American Water Spaniel is rare for a reason. It’s a specialist’s dog, deeply loyal but a bit reserved, and prone to health issues like cardiac problems and balding patches that can surprise new owners. The Toller’s price tag stings, but you’re paying for broader genetic diversity and a dog that thrives in modern active homes. If you want a partner in adventure who’ll greet every day like a game, get the Toller. If you want a quiet, capable companion for backwater hunts and moderate hikes, the American Water Spaniel might be your quiet gem. But only if you’re okay with limited breeder options and vet visits that add up.